Nowcast

Uniformly Weak 11

Thin Capacity

Eleven states sit in the bottom half on jobs, safety, and schools at once. What they share isn't party or unions — it's a thin fiscal base.

Correction, Oct 9, 2026: ranks updated after adjusting crime rates for FBI reporting coverage. In this piece, Georgia's Safety rank moved from 23rd to 27th. It is now in the bottom half on all three pillars, so the group is 11 states, not 10. Every group average, count, and comparison below is recomputed with Georgia in and compared with the other 39 states. The scoreboard image is redrawn with current ranks. The thin-capacity pattern holds. The poverty and diversity splits got sharper. The local school-funding gap got smaller, 32.7% versus 43.2% (it was 31.1% versus 43.9%), because Georgia funds most of its schools locally.

Jobs, safety, and schools are a state's operating system. The States nowcast ranks every state on those three pillars. This piece looks at one end of that scoreboard: the Uniformly Weak 11 — states in the bottom half on all three at once.

They are: New Mexico, Oklahoma, Nevada, Oregon, Alaska, Arizona, North Carolina, New York, Michigan, Alabama, and Georgia.

I compared them with the other 39 states across about sixty structural indicators from Census, BEA, BLS, Pew, FEMA, and related primary sources. The question is simple: what do these eleven have in common that the rest of the country doesn't?

States nowcast scoreboard — Uniformly Weak. Bottom half on Jobs, Safety, and Schools at once, ordered most uniformly weak first. 1 New Mexico blended 50 (Jobs 31, Safety 50, Schools 50); 2 Oklahoma blended 49 (Jobs 45, Safety 39, Schools 47); 3 Nevada blended 48 (Jobs 48, Safety 41, Schools 42); 4 Oregon blended 47 (Jobs 46, Safety 37, Schools 45); 5 Alaska blended 46 (Jobs 33, Safety 40, Schools 49); 6 Arizona blended 45 (Jobs 40, Safety 36, Schools 43); 7 North Carolina blended 43 (Jobs 44, Safety 35, Schools 28); 8 New York blended 40 (Jobs 43, Safety 30, Schools 30); 9 Michigan blended 36 (Jobs 34, Safety 28, Schools 38); 10 Alabama blended 38 (Jobs 32, Safety 26, Schools 41); 11 Georgia blended 35 (Jobs 37, Safety 27, Schools 29). Ranks 1 best / 50 worst. Source: henrycarstens.com/states · nowcast · as of 2026-10-09.
Bottom half on Jobs, Safety, and Schools at once. Ordered most uniformly weak first. Ranks as of Oct 9, 2026. Full ranks at henrycarstens.com/states.

The common thread

These eleven aren't defined by one region, one labor regime, or one ideology. The shared pattern is fiscal and economic thinness.

1. Higher poverty, lower real income. Ten of the eleven have poverty above the other-39 median. Nine have below-median real per-capita income (BEA income adjusted for local prices). Group poverty averages 13.1% versus a 10.9% other-39 median (US 12.1%). Real per-capita income averages $72.3k versus $76.7k.

2. Schools funded more from state and federal money, less from local. Nine of the eleven get a below-median share of K-12 revenue from local sources — mostly property taxes. Eight get an above-median federal share. Local share averages 32.7% versus a 43.2% median for the other 39 (the US figure is also 43.2%). Nevada (16.3%) and New Mexico (16.7%) sit near the bottom nationally. New York (50.9%) and Georgia (48.6%) are the exceptions.

Money level isn't the shared trait; money source is. Group per-pupil spending ($17.1k) is basically the same as the other 39 ($17.7k). New York spends the most in the country ($31.9k). Arizona spends $12.0k (#48). Oklahoma is #47.

3. Heavier reliance on federal transfers. Eight of the eleven have above-median government transfers as a share of personal income. Nine have an above-median federal share of state general revenue. Transfers average 20.2% of personal income versus an 18.3% median for the other 39 (US 17.7%). Alaska (#2) and Arizona (#3) are among the most federally dependent state budgets in the country.

Adult attainment runs the same direction: eight of the eleven sit below median on high-school completion, and seven below median on bachelor's degrees. Nevada and New Mexico rank #48 and #47 on high-school completion.

Those factors move together. Poverty, transfers, school-finance mix, and attainment are one broad low-capacity cluster with several faces — not four independent causes.

What else shows up

Two more patterns sit under the capacity story.

More diverse populations. All eleven are below the other-39 median on non-Hispanic white share (group mean 55.5% vs. 71.8% median; US 56.3%). The diversity comes from different sources: Hispanic populations in the Southwest, Black populations in Alabama, Georgia, North Carolina, New York, and Michigan, and Indigenous populations in Alaska, Oklahoma, New Mexico, and Arizona.

That describes who lives in these states. It is not a cause. In US data, composition is tangled up with income, history, rurality, and how crime and test scores get measured. Don't treat it as an explanation by itself.

Western public land and hazard exposure. Five of the eleven are among the twelve most federally owned states. Eight have above-median FEMA expected-annual-loss rates. Federal land averages 26.4% of state area versus a 4.7% median for the other 39. The Indigenous pattern is deep but narrow: four of the seven states with the largest American Indian / Alaska Native shares sit in this group (Alaska #1, New Mexico #2, Oklahoma #4, Arizona #7), along with large tribal, ANCSA, or reservation land bases.

What does not define them

The usual suspects don't separate this group from the other 39.

Three archetypes inside the eleven

No eleven-state group is one profile. Fit ranges from nearly complete (New Mexico, Arizona) down to thin (New York, then Georgia). Roughly three shapes:

  1. Indigenous / resource / public-land West (strongest fit): New Mexico, Alaska, Oklahoma, Arizona, plus Nevada and Oregon on land and school finance. High Indigenous share or federal land, oil- or government-heavy economies, thin local school tax base.
  2. Thin-public-sector Sun Belt growers: Arizona, Nevada, North Carolina, and Georgia. Fast growth, low union density, mostly low per-pupil spend — growth that hasn't translated into pillar strength. Georgia fits on growth and unions but not on school finance: it raises 48.6% of K-12 revenue locally, above the US figure.
  3. Legacy high-capacity states with a different problem: New York, Michigan, and partly Oregon. Higher spending, more unionized, lower hazard. They share the poverty/transfers core and little else. Alabama is a Deep South variant of the low-capacity core.

New York fits the structural profile least. Rich, highly unionized, the top K-12 spender, low hazard, schools funded locally (50.9%). Its weakness looks like inequality (high poverty next to high income), population loss, and a weak Jobs reading — a separate case.

Oregon is half a fit. Well educated, unionized (15.1%), high-cost. It shares poverty, transfers, and a below-median local school share, but its Jobs rank is doing a lot of the work. In Oregon, cost and jobs look like the questions, more than capacity.

Georgia is the newest and a partial fit. Poverty is above the median (12.6%) and real per-capita income is low ($67.6k, #44). But transfers sit near the median and its schools lean on local money. It made the list on a Safety rank of 27, just past the line.

Oklahoma is the archetype: high poverty, oil-cyclical, Indigenous-jurisdiction complexity, very low K-12 spend (#47), weak on all three pillars from low capacity rather than from one swinging policy.

What this does and doesn't say

Close

The story people expect — that uniformly weak states share a party, a labor regime, or a spending level — doesn't hold. What holds is quieter: higher poverty, more transfer dependence, and school systems that lean on state and federal money instead of a local tax base. That's thin capacity, not a single ideology.

That doesn't tell any state what to do. It does tell you where the scoreboard is pointing.

See where your state sits: https://www.henrycarstens.com/states

--h

Questions or corrections? Write me at .

Method. Group means are unweighted. "Median" means the median of the other 39 states. Safety ranks use FBI crime rates adjusted for reporting coverage. Ranks as of Oct 9, 2026. Real income = BEA 2025 per-capita personal income ÷ BEA 2024 regional price parity. Sources: Census ACS 2024 1-year; Census Annual Survey of School System Finances FY2024; BEA SAINC/SARPP/SAGDP; Pew FY2024 state revenue shares; BLS Union Members 2025; NCSL; Ballotpedia (Oct 2026); FEMA NRI v1.20; CRS R42346. Full tables and per-state matrix in the companion study.